Trying again to stop deals that delay generic drugs
Submitted by Debra on Wednesday, 4 February 2009
2 Comments
If a conspiracy falls in the forest and everyone within a country mile hears it, are big companies still guilty of cheating the public?
The Federal Trade Commission thinks so. It joined California Attorney General Jerry Brown this week in suing four companies in federal court in California to try to stop the deal.
Problem is, the trade commission's tried similar lawsuits before against drug makers who get together for a rousing round of "keep the generics off the market for fun and profit." It failed at least in part because the Bush Justice Department sided with the companies.
Usually, a conspiracy is a secret plot. Not this one. It's played out for years in open court and news releases. Everyone from drug manufacturers to the government to Congress knows how it works. No one's been able to stop it, though.
The game works like this:
- A company figures out how to produce a generic version of a drug still under patent. In many cases, the general defense is "we used your ingredients, but we didn't rip off your recipe."
- The patent holder sues in federal court to block the generic.
- Meanwhile, the patent holder and would-be generic producer figure out that everyone could save a pile of lawyer's fees if the patent holder would pay the other company to not produce the generic. The lawsuit goes away, and everyone's happy.
Everyone, that is, except consumers who continue to pay 50 to 80 percent more for a brand name than they would for a generic.
There are other variations of the game. Sometimes, the patent holder lets the generic go on the market in exchange for part of the royalties. In other cases, the patent holder rushes a generic into production when faced with the threat of competition.
That's what happened this fall when AstraZeneca agreed to let Par Pharmaceutical produce a generic version of the asthma medication Pulmicort. The move came the same day the U.S. Food and Drug Administration approved Israeli company Teva Pharmaceutical's generic version of the same drug. AstraZeneca is suing Teva.
Par is one of the companies included in the new lawsuit, which involves the testosterone-replacement drug Androgel. The brand-name version is Solvay Pharmaceuticals' second-highest grossing drug, earning about $400 million in annual sales, according to the lawsuit.
Shortly after the FDA approved generic versions that Par, Watson Pharmaceuticals and Paddock Laboratories had planned, Solvay cut a deal: The three would get a share of Solvay's profits in return for holding off on a generic until 2010
The FTC contends the maneuver violates the Hatch-Waxman Act, passed in 1984 with an aim of getting money-saving generics to market more quickly.
Drug company lawyers spin it as a good deal for the public because the agreement gets the medication to market five years before the patent expires, CNN Money says.
Even if the FTC loses this round - and it might not without the Bush Justice Department around to shoot it in the back - there could be legislative help on the way. Wisconsin Democrat Herb Kohl introduced a bill Tuesday, the same day the suit was filed, that would make it perfectly clear that such deals are illegal.
It's similar to a bill he introduced in 2007 that wound up with 10 co-sponsors. One was Barack Obama.
What do you want to bet the Justice Department changes its position this time around?
Copyright 2009 Debra Legg. All rights reserved.
Similar Posts:
- When faced with competition, suddenly drug makers can produce generics
- Epiblogue: The curious case of the generic drug that’s not
- Drug companies robbing everybody to pay Paul
- A new law needed to get current law enforced on generics
- Here’s a big surprise: Health insurance costs could continue to rise
another reason the profit motive needs to be cleansed from the medical field. You have drug company execs putting money ahead of what’s best for patients. Makes me want to vomit.
Good grief! I agree with Vanilla Cokehead: makes ya wanna barf! Healthcare for profit: it’s all about greed. Hopefully there will be progress made in limiting the game. What’s scary is that the health of human beings is the final chip on table. Not right!
Food »
Egg-free strawberry muffins
In part because I live in a place where egg replacer isn’t readily available and in part because I’m tired of toting ingredients when I’m on the road, I’ve been experimenting lately with baking with …
Girl Gone Wonk »
Part of the digital divide will never be bridged – so be it
Two contradictory tidbits from a CNet story this morning about an Federal Communications Commission report on expanding broadband Internet access to more parts of the country:
A third of adults who don’t have broadband at home …
Health »
Confessions of a closet snacker
Back when my job involved actually leaving my house, there wasn’t a lunchbox in the world big enough for me.
I usually ran out the door without breakfast, triggering the need to pack snack one. The …
News »
A SWAT for trying to impose values from afar
What’s worse than a YouTube video showing a developmentally disabled boy being bullied?
A court verdict in Italy that finds Google executives guilty of invasion of privacy because the video was posted to begin with – …
Reviews »
YouTube safety mode is nothing special
It’s ironic that Google rolled out Safety Mode parental controls for YouTube in the same week that it made gmail unsafe for some folks in its careless rollout of Buzz.
Some of the early things I’d …
School days »
Reading Across America – in a virtual way
We’ve read the books, and we’ve eaten the cake at the library. That’s all old Cat in the Hat now. What else could we do to celebrate Dr. Seuss’s birthday and Read Across America, I …
By the way
08/18/2009 | 1:34 pm
Sometimes life is all about timing. There’s a chance the soldier took his protective goggles off briefly during training in The Box – 1,000 barren square miles at Fort Irwin where soldiers prepare for desert warfare. Then ...
07/24/2009 | 9:47 pm
So there I was last month, stressing until 2 in the morning over Dad’s “welcome home” cake, worried that it would be ugly or dry or have the wrong color stars. Silly, silly girl. If I’d ...
06/12/2009 | 12:05 pm
I’m kind of frustrated this morning because I don’t have girls. I don’t even know any girls young enough to appreciate this. But if I did, I’d be all over the tutu tutorial – say that ...
05/30/2009 | 8:17 am
Poor Boots. He wakes up every morning chirping with the birds and with a cheery greeting. “It’s a beautiful day!” Somewhere along the line, though, the grind of the world beats the beauty out of it ...
05/21/2009 | 11:18 pm
On one level, it’s simple: When you’re about to fall, just let go and fall. Trying to stop the tumble or, even worse, flailing your arms and legs as you land will make it worse. Somewhere ...
05/20/2009 | 9:03 pm
05/20/2009 | 10:18 am
This one landed in my Twitter stream just as Boots was diving into a bowl of … Cocoa Puffs: “New peanut flour warning for General Mills cereals.” Luckily, he’s not the child who’s allergic and Big ...
05/19/2009 | 12:56 am
From the country that wants to censor the Internet worldwide in the name of protecting its children comes another bizarre project, also in the name of “protecting children” The British have launched a database, at a ...
05/18/2009 | 11:38 pm
Do I ever feel like a dolt after my post last night lamenting the difficulties of finding dye-free snow-cone syrups. I went to a Middle Eastern market today to pick up some hummus ingredients and ran ...
05/16/2009 | 8:16 pm
05/15/2009 | 10:15 pm
Six hundred and eight three killed in Afghanistan. Four thousand, two hundred and ninety six killed in Iraq. Many stories of incredible lives, often amazing sacrifices. This is one such story. Army Maj. Steven Hutchison survived two ...
To subscribe