A $1b a year failure, courtesy of NCLB
Submitted by Debra on Thursday, 20 November 2008
2 Comments
I've done a fantastic job showing Big Guy how to tie his shoes. He knows everything he needs to know to tie his shoes. But he still can't tie his stinking shoes.
And there are accusations that I've taken payola from certain shoe companies.
In a nutshell, that's the state of the $1 billion-a-year -- $6 billion total so far -- Reading First. The program, which is supposed to help get students off to a good start, is central to the Bush Administration's No Child Left Behind.
It helps, all right, much in the way the guys' help me with dinner every night. They're not really providing that much assistance when it comes right down to it.
Which is pretty much the state of Reading First, according to audit released today.
- Reading First has increased the amount of time spent teaching reading.
- Students in the program are getting better at "decoding" -- identifying letters and words.
- Students in the program are not any better at reading comprehension than their peers.
Skeptical that we can afford President-Elect Obama's $10 billion-a-year preschool plan? I think I see a way to get us 10 percent there.
What's the worst that could happen? Failure? Reading First's doing that already.
Even federal officials are at a loss as to how to make this one look good.
“Advocates for the program will be pleased that it’s shown a positive correlation on (improved) decoding skills ... the focus of the program,” said Grover J. “Russ” Whitehurst, the outgoing director of U.S. Education Department’s research arm told "Education Week." “I don’t think anyone should be celebrating the fact that the federal government invested $6 billion in a reading program that has shown no effects on reading comprehension.”
The program already was under fire, with Congress slashing its funding 60 percent this year in the wake of a report this spring that questioned its effectiveness and accusations that a high-level administrator steered work toward a company that paid him to lobby.
Others, such as Fresno State education Professor Elaine Garan, have questioned the program from the start, challenging the data used as the basis for a "scientific approach to reading."
The damage, of course, extends far beyond the children who aren't being helped in schools where we're investing $1 billion a year. The true cost is in the "drill and kill" mentality that's sacrificed the joy of reading on the altar of sight words.
Big Guy's a victim. He loves a good yarn and, consequently, wants to jump ahead and figure out what's next based on pictures and what he thinks the logical story progression is. Except that's a negative in today's classroom. Must do the diabolical DIBELS first!
I play the game, because that's the way he's being evaluated and judged and because I get that the building blocks are important. But late at night, in the still of storytime, we still get rolling drunk on the story itself. It didn't cost me a billion a year to figure out how to do it, either.
Copyright 2008 Debra Legg. All rights reserved.
Oh my goodness!! I am (ashamedly) a thirty-something with Boots’ tendencies toward finger-jabbing and angry accusations...
Amen. NCLB was a disaster from day one. It was an attempt by the Bush administration to make claims that education was important to them, when the program was really designed to bust teachers’ unions. Terrible program from a terrible president.
Not to mention a slick way to funnel money to dear friends in the standardized testing industry. Because we are all about accountability.
Food »
Egg-free pumpkin scones
For some crazy reason – probably our “Cinnamon Roll Friday” tradition – the guys have decided that they’re entitled to a fresh-from-the-oven breakfast every morning of late. For some reason that’s even crazier, I’ve gone …
Girl Gone Wonk »
Take my kids’ dessert, Michelle. Please.
Note to Sara Palin: Michelle Obama is free to stop by my house any evening and tell my kids they can’t have dessert. After seven-plus years of this war, I’m battle fatigued. Michelle would probably …
Health »
If you’re laying off nurses, you better have a backup plan
The lack of health-care workers in schools is nothing new.
We saw the impact when Big Guy was in kindergarten and cooled his heels in the office for half a day after a snooty secretary diagnosed …
News »
Forcing myself into little circles
I’ve come to the conclusion recently that my perfect friend would be a geeky food-allergic liberal with quirky sense of humor, an obsessive interest in education issues and a tolerance for cute crap my kids …
Reviews »
Bad Kitty’s the purrfect read
In this corner we have Big Guy, who’s bored with every book I bring home and isn’t fond of fiction.
In this corner we have Boots, who could devour Step 3 books if he wanted to, …
School days »
When Accelerated Reader slams on the brakes
It’s a good thing Accelerated Reader wasn’t around when I was in third grade. I doubt there would have been AR tests for the Perry Mason novels I loved.
For unindoctrinated uninitiated, Accelerated Reader bills itself …
By the way
08/18/2009 | 1:34 pm
Sometimes life is all about timing. There’s a chance the soldier took his protective goggles off briefly during training in The Box – 1,000 barren square miles at Fort Irwin where soldiers prepare for desert warfare. Then ...
07/24/2009 | 9:47 pm
So there I was last month, stressing until 2 in the morning over Dad’s “welcome home” cake, worried that it would be ugly or dry or have the wrong color stars. Silly, silly girl. If I’d ...
06/12/2009 | 12:05 pm
I’m kind of frustrated this morning because I don’t have girls. I don’t even know any girls young enough to appreciate this. But if I did, I’d be all over the tutu tutorial – say that ...
05/30/2009 | 8:17 am
Poor Boots. He wakes up every morning chirping with the birds and with a cheery greeting. “It’s a beautiful day!” Somewhere along the line, though, the grind of the world beats the beauty out of it ...
05/21/2009 | 11:18 pm
On one level, it’s simple: When you’re about to fall, just let go and fall. Trying to stop the tumble or, even worse, flailing your arms and legs as you land will make it worse. Somewhere ...
05/20/2009 | 9:03 pm
05/20/2009 | 10:18 am
This one landed in my Twitter stream just as Boots was diving into a bowl of … Cocoa Puffs: “New peanut flour warning for General Mills cereals.” Luckily, he’s not the child who’s allergic and Big ...
05/19/2009 | 12:56 am
From the country that wants to censor the Internet worldwide in the name of protecting its children comes another bizarre project, also in the name of “protecting children” The British have launched a database, at a ...
05/18/2009 | 11:38 pm
Do I ever feel like a dolt after my post last night lamenting the difficulties of finding dye-free snow-cone syrups. I went to a Middle Eastern market today to pick up some hummus ingredients and ran ...
05/16/2009 | 8:16 pm
05/15/2009 | 10:15 pm
Six hundred and eight three killed in Afghanistan. Four thousand, two hundred and ninety six killed in Iraq. Many stories of incredible lives, often amazing sacrifices. This is one such story. Army Maj. Steven Hutchison survived two ...
To subscribe